Broken Trail and Siam Bend

Broken TrailsOne catalyst for my rekindled interest in riverfront property is the film Broken Trail and Siam Bend. In this 1898 frontier epic, Prentice Ritter, (played by Robert Duvall) and his nephew Tom Harte, drive a herd of 500 mustangs from Oregon to Sheridan, Wyoming. Along the trail they encounter a group of Chinese girls who’ve been sold into a life of prostitution and are being carted off to Rocky Mountain mining camps by the conniving Captain Billy Fender. “A man who sins while drunk shall pay when sober.” Fender’s fate is sealed by his own words as the ‘sobered-up’ scoundrel soon dangles at the end of Tom’s rope.

‘Uncle Print’ and nephew Tom (Thomas Haden Church) are accompanied on the horse drive by Henry ‘Hank’ Gilpin (Scott Cooper), an educated adventurer who ‘fiddles’ his way into the drama. The chivalrous cowboys become protectors to the girls after realizing that ‘hungry wolves’ — Big Rump Kate (Rusty Schwimmer) and her ravenous gold-miner clientele — would otherwise devour them.

Siam Bend Wy Bragg Creek Calgary CL RanchWhat is the reference to Siam Bend (my blog URL title) you ask? There are several gorgeous sunrise and sunset scenes by the Snake River in Wyoming. In one instance, Prentice and Nola Johns (Gretta Scacchi) are sitting by the flowing waters on a serene night. Nola asks about the women in “Mr Ritter’s” life and Print reveals that “Ah, well, there’ve been a few” but true ‘abiding love’ seems to be reserved “only for a lucky few”… and he does not count himself as one of the fortunates. Nola challenges that belief, and Print laughs; “I have about as much chance of finding ‘that gal’ as I do becoming the King of Siam.” Later in the film Print is faced with the choice of taking Nola as his life partner or sending her off to chaperone the young Celestials (Chinese girls). Siam Bend. Nola & RitterRitter has grown accustomed to the lonesome cowboy lifestyle and he opts to send Nola on to San Francisco with his surrogate daughters. Print later buys some ranch land at the very spot on the Snake River where he and Nola dipped their toes in the water. A special place he named Siam Bend. The King of Siam indeed!

GoodbyeThere are many life-changing ‘which fork in the road?’ moments in Broken Trail … Tom takes his uncle’s offer and embarks on a risky new venture — the ‘horse bid-ness’ … Nola jumps aboard the wagon and escapes her life servicing dirty gold-miners … Print Ritter bids Nola adieu and stays on his solitary ‘bachelor’ path … and Sun Fu (Gwendoline Yeo) summons inner courage by exiting the stagecoach bound for San Francisco, and chooses to start a new life with Tom in Wyoming.

Siam Bend Nola's LetterIn Broken Trail’s final moments (fast-forward to 1912) you see an aged Print Ritter sitting by the fire in his cabin and later by the River (Siam Bend) reading Nola’s letters. These are poignant scenes. Nola, through her written words (conveyed via voice over) expresses her gratitude and updates Print on the progress of the ‘girls’ (Ghee Moon and Ging Wa);

“They have grown into wonderful young ladies … I see them often and they always ask of you. Promise me you will not laugh at an old woman when I tell you that I still dream of the time when I splashed my feet in the water with you … There are so many things someone wishes they might change about their lives … I want to say that it is you and you alone that will abide in me in my final hour. Thank you Mr. Ritter for giving me back my life … even if I could not share it with you.”

Nola’s letter touches Print deeply. As he reflects, a sense of regret is etched upon his face. ‘What might have been?’ Without uttering a word, Print’s eyes speak volumes and you can almost read his thoughts (a quote from earlier in the film);

“I get rousted out of my sleep sometimes… I find there’s something frightening ’bout that hour of the night ’cause there ain’t no foolin’ yourself ’bout what you done or what you hadn’t done with your life.”

Setting and Cinematography: The riverfront scenes in Broken Trail were visually stunning. There were several wide-angle shots along the Snake River in Wyoming with the Tetons in the background. There were also many scenes showing the Canadian Rockies in the background. This change in geography does not detract … only those with no imagination would find fault.

Broken Trail was primarily filmed at the CL Ranch outside of Calgary, Alberta. The Ranch also has its own ‘authentic’ frontier town where Lonesome Dove and many other westerns were filmed. Here is a bit more on > CL Ranch History.

IMG_6419Since much of the production was filmed at the CL, I am guessing that several river scenes were taken on nearby Bragg Creek, Jumping Pound Creek and Bow River, with the Rockies and Kananaskis country in the background. See general > location

Sidebar: Just a bit ‘up river’ from many Broken Trail river scene locations is Bragg Creek’s Elbow Falls… the shooting location for Bourne Legacy’s opening scene where Aaron Cross (Jeremy Renner) emerges from the icy river.

More Broken Trail Background: There are many reviews that do better justice to Broken Trail than I can here. Suffice to say, I found the production and the cinematography to be superb! A must see if you’re a fan of westerns and the great outdoors. Amazing sound and picture quality on BluRay!

Donaldina Cameron

Donaldina Cameron: While only obliquely mentioned in Broken Trail (when Print shares with Nola that he has; “found a place in San Francisco that will care for the children”Donaldina Cameron is an important part of the story. A courageous and compassionate woman, Cameron, is credited with rescuing thousands of young Chinese girls who might have otherwise been doomed to a life of forced prostitution. Read her compelling biography > Fierce Compassion and short video on Cameron’s life/mission

trail6Smallpox Bob: Alan Geoffrion’s Broken Trail story is fictional, yet delivers an accurate depiction of events of the day. There is one troubling aspect of the film, however, that evidently perpetuates a falsehood. Specifically, introduction of the Smallpox Bob character and his ‘deathly trade’… providing indians with infected blankets. Ward Churchill wrote extensively about ‘willful introduction’ of smallpox to indian tribes. But these accounts have since been debunked and Churchill faced plagiarism and other academic fraud charges. How much was Geofffrian’s story influenced by Churchill? Unknown. Yet those who support the ‘infected blanket trade’ thesis, do so on flimsy factual grounds.

This is not to say despicable events and injustices were not visited upon native americans. But the smallpox blanket trade, as told in Broken Trail, was likely embellished or simply wrong. NOTE: The Amherst-Bouquet letters circa 1763 have oft been cited as proof of a ‘germ warfare’ plot against native tribes, yet there is no historical evidence to show Colonet Bouquet’s plans were ever carried out.

Sidebar: Read the interesting backstory re when/why/how Siam was renamed Thailand

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

My Mt Bachelor, Bend Oregon Deschutes River Property (video) below is now for rent. More info here


6 thoughts on “Broken Trail and Siam Bend

  1. Debbie, While Broken Trail is a ‘derived’ tale, certainly much of this story was ‘based on’ real events and circumstances. Screenplay author Alan Geoffrion stated that “everything was either from private diaries, correspondences and letters.”

    • Hi Rebecca,
      I think the closest to a ‘book’ would be Alan Geoffrion’s background post:
      “I developed the story idea for BROKEN TRAIL in 2003. I was on my way to Alberta to work with legendary actor Robert Duvall on the feature Open Range, when Duvall suggested I visit the Haythorne family at their ranch in Ogallala, Nebraska. There, Waldo Haythorne described how his grandfather, Walter, took 700 horses from eastern Oregon back to the Rosebud Reservation in South Dakota. This rich episode, coupled with my fascination with both the role of minorities and the amazing strength of women in the Old West, formed the core of Broken Trail.” More >

  2. I do not understand why the author felt it necessary to defend the white mans actions against the native population ! The white mans actions were by all accounts Genocidel ! If he can slaughter tens of millions of Buffalo to reach his ends it is not a far stretch to contaminated blankets ! It is what it was no more no less !

    • Hardly a defense of “actions against the native population” … In my post I pointed out that there were no doubt many atrocities committed versus native tribes — many despicable acts verses those who lands and rights were taken and trampled. But I was curious about the Smallpox Bob anecdote in Broken Trail and the more research I did the more fallacies in this retelling. Since Broken Trail was loosely based on real life stories, I felt it appropriate to set the record straight.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s